What Should Your RIA Insurance Broker Actually Be Doing for You?
Your insurance broker sends you an application, gets you a quote, and asks for payment. But what should they actually be doing for your RIA? Here's what to expect from a broker, from completing applications to comparing policies and managing renewals.
Imagine a prospective client comes to your RIA.
Instead of scheduling a conversation to understand their financial situation, you send them a questionnaire. They spend two hours completing it, you review their answers, select an investment strategy, and send them a recommendation.
No conversation about their goals. No explanation of why you selected that strategy. Just some paperwork and a recommendation.
Would you consider that a good client experience?
Probably not.
Yet that's remarkably similar to how some RIAs purchase their own insurance.
Your broker sends you an application. You spend a couple of hours completing it. A few weeks later, you receive a quote. You pay the premium, receive your policy, and repeat the process next year.
Which raises a reasonable question: What exactly should your insurance broker be doing for you?
Your Broker Should Understand Your Business
Insurance is an enormous industry. You can insure a car, a cruise ship, a cannabis operation, or a Registered Investment Adviser.
All four involve insurance, but the expertise required to insure each one is different.
The same applies to insurance agencies. An agency might have hundreds of employees and decades of experience. That doesn't necessarily mean the person handling your account understands RIAs.
Consider your own business. Two clients might have identical account balances but completely different financial situations. You wouldn't recommend the same investment strategy simply because their portfolios are the same size.
RIA insurance works much the same way.
Two firms managing $500 million can have very different insurance needs depending on their investment strategies, services, and business structures.
At Box Professional Insurance (BPI), we work exclusively with RIAs. Before our first conversation, we review the firm's Form ADV and Part 2A brochure to understand its operations and identify potential exposures.
That preparation helps us arrive with informed questions and an initial view of what coverage may make sense.
Your broker should understand your business before recommending how to insure it.
Your Broker Should Help You Complete the Application
Let's talk about everyone's favorite part of buying insurance: the application.
Nobody enjoys completing these things. They're long, the questions can be confusing, and you might only look at one once a year.
But here's the problem.
The application is how the insurance company learns what your firm does.
If your answers don't accurately describe your operations, the insurer could price your firm incorrectly or offer coverage that doesn't fit.
We've seen this happen. One RIA incorrectly classified part of its investments on an application, making the firm appear to have more exposure to private investments than it actually did. That mistake affected the pricing it received.
We covered that example in detail in Same AUM, Different Premium: What RIA E&O Insurance Really Costs.
This is why BPI completes applications with our clients.
Rather than emailing a blank PDF and leaving you to figure it out, we schedule a working session to complete it together.
You understand your business better than we ever will. But we understand how insurance companies interpret these questions.
Combining that knowledge makes the process easier and helps ensure the application accurately describes your firm.
We've found that applications clients might otherwise spend a couple of hours completing can often be finished together in approximately 30 minutes.
Less time on paperwork. More confidence in what's being submitted.
Your Broker Should Know Where to Take Your Business
Not every insurance company is a good fit for every RIA.
Some are more competitive for traditional wealth managers. Others may be better suited to firms managing private funds, alternative investments, or more complex operations.
And even when two insurers are willing to cover the same firm, their pricing and policy language can differ considerably.
That's why your broker's knowledge of the RIA insurance marketplace matters.
If your broker only approaches one insurance company, how do you know whether that quote is competitive?
You might receive a $7,000 quote and assume that's simply what your insurance costs.
But perhaps another insurer would offer comparable coverage for $5,500. Or perhaps the $7,000 policy includes important protection that the cheaper option excludes.
Your broker should be able to explain which insurers were considered, why they were appropriate for your firm, and what makes the available options different.
That doesn't mean every RIA needs five quotes. Sometimes only two or three insurers are a good fit.
What matters is knowing that your broker evaluated the right options, not simply the most convenient ones.
Your Broker Should Show You What You're Buying
This is where we believe an insurance broker provides some of the greatest value.
RIA professional liability insurance is not standardized.
Two policies can have the same premium, limit, and deductible but respond very differently to a claim.
The differences are often buried in the policy's definitions, exclusions, and endorsements.
We've reviewed an RIA's policy that excluded nondiscretionary asset management. The problem was that the firm managed 100% of its assets on a nondiscretionary basis.
The policy contained an exclusion affecting the firm's entire business.
You wouldn't discover that by looking at the premium.
And you shouldn't have to read 70 pages of insurance language to find out whether your broker's recommendation makes sense.
At BPI, we use RIAview, our side-by-side insurance comparison, to walk clients through the available options.
We compare the firm's existing policy when applicable, identify meaningful differences in coverage, explain why certain insurers declined, and show how each option fits the firm's operations.
Then we make a recommendation and explain our reasoning.
For a real example, read What Changed When a $1 Billion RIA Put Its Insurance Program Under Review. That review identified coverage that didn't fit the firm's investment profile, uncovered a significant gap in its crime insurance, and resulted in a stronger alignment of coverage and cost.
The point isn't that the cheapest policy is always wrong or that the most expensive policy is always better.
It's that you should understand what you're buying and why.
The time to understand your insurance contract is before you purchase it, not when you're trying to determine whether a claim is covered.
Your Broker Should Still Be Working for You After the Sale
Your business doesn't stand still between renewals.
You might add a custodian, launch a private fund, expand your services, or grow your assets under management substantially.
Any of those changes could affect your insurance needs.
Your broker should be helping you identify and evaluate those changes, not simply waiting until next year to send another application.
At BPI, we monitor certain changes in our clients' businesses that could affect their coverage.
Recently, we identified that a client had added another custodian with its own insurance requirements.
We reviewed the client's existing policies and confirmed that the firm already met those requirements.
We sent a quick email letting the client know what we'd found and that no action was needed.
The client didn't have to ask us to check.
That's the type of relationship we want to build.
And when renewal comes around, the same principle applies. Your broker should review what's changed, evaluate the available options, and explain whether staying with your current insurer still makes sense.
Sometimes the best recommendation is to renew exactly what you have.
But that should be an informed decision, not simply the easiest one.
Five Questions to Ask Your Insurance Broker
You don't need to change brokers to evaluate whether you're getting the service you should expect.
Start by asking:
- Will you help me complete the application? Or am I expected to figure it out myself?
- Which insurance companies are you considering, and why? Can you explain why they're appropriate for my firm?
- Can you show me how the policies differ? Beyond premium, limits, and deductibles, what am I actually buying?
- What exclusions should I be concerned about? How do they relate to the services my firm provides?
- What are you doing for my firm between renewals? How are you helping me evaluate changes in my business?
A good broker should be comfortable answering these questions.
You may find that your current broker is doing an excellent job. Or you might realize you've been handling more of the insurance process yourself than you should.
Either way, you'll have a better understanding of what you're getting from the relationship.
See What a Different RIA Insurance Process Looks Like
You wouldn't expect your clients to become investment experts before working with you. They rely on your knowledge to help them make informed decisions.
We believe your relationship with your insurance broker should work the same way.
At Box Professional Insurance, we work exclusively with RIAs. We've built our process around understanding your firm, doing the heavy lifting, and giving you a clear recommendation you can evaluate for yourself.
We review your business before the first conversation. We complete applications with you. We evaluate the insurance marketplace, compare policy language through RIAview, and explain why we're recommending a particular option.
And we keep working to make that process require less of your time.
If you're not sure whether your current insurance broker is delivering that level of service, we'd welcome the opportunity to show you what a different approach looks like.
If you already have coverage, send us your current policies before our discovery call. We'll review what you have, discuss how your firm operates, and identify questions worth exploring.
You don't need to commit to changing brokers to have that conversation.
The first step is a 30-minute discovery call.
Need Expert Insurance Guidance?
Our team specializes in insurance solutions for Registered Investment Advisors. Let's discuss how we can protect your practice.
Get in Touch